33 minutes ago by Julie Cart, Los Angeles Times
In the small, rural community of Reserve, children waiting for the school bus gather inside wooden and mesh cages provided as protection from wolves. Parents consider the "kid cages" a reasonable precaution.
Defenders of the wolves note there have been no documented wolf attacks in New Mexico or Arizona. Fears of wolves attacking humans, they say, are overblown, and the cages nothing more than a stunt.
In 1995, the reintroduction of Canadian gray wolves into the northern Rockies ignited a furor.
Now that acrimony has cascaded into the Southwest, where the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposes to extend Endangered Species Act protections for an estimated 75 Mexican wolves in the wild in New Mexico and Arizona.
Such protections would make it illegal to kill wolves, in most instances. The new federal plan would also significantly expand the area where the wolves could roam unmolested.
To many conservatives in the West, such protections are examples of government overreach - idealistic efforts by officials who don't know what it's like to live with wolves.
"People have to stand up and defend our rights," said Wink Crigler, a fifth-generation rancher from Arizona who says guests at her tourist cabins fear they might be attacked by wolves.
Anti-wolf campaigns here - paid for by conservative political organizations antagonistic toward the federal government - often portray the animal as a savage devil preying on children.
The antipathy has encouraged scores of illegal killings of Mexican wolves, whose population dwindled to seven before federal efforts to reintroduce them began in 1998. A young male was fatally shot with an arrow a few weeks ago in the same rural Catron County that uses the kid cages.
Into this atmosphere have come federal officials who by the end of the year are expected to finalize their plan for managing Mexican wolves, a smaller and tawnier subspecies of the Canadian grays.
"With the political debate we see raging, we can't just listen to the loudest voice in the room," said Fish and Wildlife Service Director Dan Ashe. "There are many loud voices in the room. No animal engenders more polarizing emotion among Americans than does the wolf."
He could be describing the situation here: a public policy debate driven not by biology and science but emotional appeals and unalloyed partisanship.
When a previously scheduled Oct. 4 public comment hearing about wolf management was postponed by the government shutdown, advocates came out anyway, staking out nearby meeting rooms at an Albuquerque hotel.
The Save the Lobo rally, paid for by Defenders of Wildlife, featured a man in a wolf costume, children scrawling placards with crayons and people offering videotaped testimony to be forwarded to Washington.
Down the hall, the anti-wolf event was sponsored by Americans for Prosperity, an organization funded by the conservative Koch brothers. The group offered literature by Ayn Rand and screened the documentary "Wolves in Government Clothing," which equated rampaging wolves with an out-of-control federal government. Said one Arizona rancher at the event: "Is this politically driven? Absolutely."
An armed guard patrolled, made necessary, Americans for Prosperity said, by death threats from environmental groups.
The issue of public safety loomed large, with much discussion of the kid cages, boxy structures that resemble chicken coops. Photos and video of the cages have been circulated by Americans for Prosperity, although it was unclear how many exist or who requested or paid for them. Local media reports suggest at least some of them were built by students in a high school shop class.
Calls to the superintendent of schools in Reserve were not returned.
To Carolyn Nelson, a teacher in Catron County, the cages don't go far enough to protect children. She said that seven years ago her son, then 14, was out walking and came across three wolves. Frightened, he backed against a tree. One wolf stared him down while the other two circled.
Only when the boy cocked the gun he was carrying did the wolves run off.
"I think it was a miracle he wasn't killed," she said.
Crigler, the Arizona rancher, who also attended the event, said she understands the fears of the guests in her tourist cabins. "I can't tell them that they are perfectly safe. There is some degree of risk," she said. "My concern is that I see wolves habituated to people. They are meat eaters. Savages."
According to wolf researcher Carlos Carroll, who was among the scientists studying Mexican wolves for the Fish and Wildlife Service, the probability of wolves targeting humans is low.
"All we can go on is what has happened in the past," said Carroll, a conservation biologist with the Klamath Center for Conservation Research in Northern California. "There have been maybe two to three attacks in the last decade, in Canada and Alaska, where there are thousands of wolves."
Wolf advocate Michael Robinson with the nonprofit Center for Biological Diversity said he respected people's fears but added, "The risk has been greatly exaggerated for cynical reasons."
Likewise, the incidence of wolves killing cattle and sheep is actually much less common than widely believed. According to the National Agricultural Statistics Service, about a third of sheep deaths nationwide are attributable to predators, with wolves accountable for only 0.4 percent of those attacks. The data indicate that domestic dogs are responsible for nearly 20 times more sheep kills than wolves.
Similar numbers hold true for cattle, where wolf kills rank behind coyotes, domestic dogs, cougars and vultures, which have attacked calves.
Ranchers are compensated when they can prove livestock have been killed by wolves. Crigler lost three calves last year and was reimbursed by a government program, but she said the payment was below fair market value.
"It's already hard enough to make a living," she said, adding that a neighboring cattleman was getting ready to walk away from the business because of wolves.
It's undeniable that small ranchers and farmers face economic troubles - and it's common for some people to feel powerless living in states where the federal government is the landlord of more than half the landscape.
But some anti-wolf advocates in Albuquerque hold wolves responsible for such diverging issues as the depopulation of small towns to the closing of country schools.
"They attach a lot of rancor to wolf recovery that isn't about wolves," said John Horning, executive director of WildEarth Guardians, based in Santa Fe, N.M. "It's a symbol. It's about the loss of political capital, the economic decline of rural life. Wolves are a surrogate for all the changes that are happening that are very frightening."
David Spady, the California director of Americans for Prosperity and producer of the anti-wolf documentary, readily agreed that wolves are a launching pad to air an array of grievances, from taxes to state's rights.
"The whole debate over the wolf is part of other battles over the Endangered Species Act and failed government programs," said Spady, who wore silver wolf-head cuff links.
"The wolf is symbolic of a larger fact: The federal government is running roughshod over private property rights," he said. "We at the local level believe that we understand the needs of our place rather than somebody in Washington, D.C."
Explore further: Plan lifts Lower 48 wolf protections (Update)
©2013 Los Angeles Times
Distributed by MCT Information Services
subspecies vs species
Oct 29, 2013 I am trying to get a better understanding of subspecies vs species notably for humans. For example are Neanderthals a... Effect of microwave on food
Oct 26, 2013 Hello All, Does microwave radiation cause change in protein chain structure? direction of magnetic field of earth and brain
Oct 23, 2013 does direction of magnetic field influence the process occurring in brain? what are the other external factor that... Diffusion Constant
Oct 23, 2013 Hey everybody, first post here. Having some trouble with a biophysics questions. So, the question is basically this:... How does exercise accelerate glucose uptake in diabetes?
Oct 23, 2013 We're usually just told that exercise is a great way to stimulate the movement of glucose into cells. But how does it... Why the shaking in transformation?
Oct 23, 2013 When performing transformation, after adding SOC media to the newly transformed cells, we place them at 37 degrees... More from Physics Forums - Biology
Related Stories
Plan lifts Lower 48 wolf protections (Update)
Jun 07, 2013
The Obama administration is proposing to end recovery efforts for gray wolves across most of the U.S. and return management to the states.
Draft rule ends protections for gray wolves
Apr 26, 2013
Federal wildlife officials have drafted plans to lift protections for gray wolves across the Lower 48 states, a move that would end a decades-long effort that has restored the animals but only in parts of ...
Wolves to come off endangered list within 60 days
Apr 16, 2011
(AP) -- Federal wildlife officials say they will take more than 1,300 gray wolves in the Northern Rockies off the endangered species list within 60 days.
Wolves howl because they care
Aug 22, 2013
When a member of the wolf pack leaves the group, the howling by those left behind isn't a reflection of stress but of the quality of their relationships. So say researchers based on a study of nine wolves ...
Wolf negotiations resume, but no consensus
Dec 03, 2010
(AP) -- Interior Secretary Ken Salazar and governors from three Northern Rockies states resumed negotiations Thursday to remove the region's wolves from the endangered list, but reached no conclusions.
Endangered wolves at NY preserve produce 8 pups
May 08, 2012
(AP) -- Eight rare Mexican wolf pups have been born at a preserve in the New York City suburbs, a development that could aid the federal program that has reintroduced the endangered species to the wild.
Recommended for you
15 Hawaii animals, plants added to endangered list
5 hours ago
The federal government says an eyeless shrimp and 14 other Hawaii creatures and plants have been added to the endangered species list.
Dry seeding examined for Wheatbelt crops
8 hours ago
Agronomy scientists have been conducting a series of experiments to help Wheatbelt farmers climate-proof their crops.
Biological activity and biotransformation of enniatins from Fusarium fungi
8 hours ago
Mould species of the genera Fusarium and Altenaria are considered the most important threats to Norwegian grain cereals because they produce toxins which can be a potential risk to food safety.
Porpoises on European coasts maintain their populations but migrate southwards
8 hours ago
Seven oceanographic research vessels and three light aircrafts from the SCANSII Project have recorded the abundance and distribution of small cetaceans in the waters of the European Atlantic shelf. Their results reveal that ...
Radical new 'Trojan Female' pest control approach shows great promise
9 hours ago
An innovative, non-lethal approach to pest management has the potential to become a "game-changer" in providing lasting and effective control in a wide range of insect and animal pests, according to New Zealand scientists ...
LA Zoo treats 21 condors for lead poisoning
Oct 29, 2013
Officials say a record 21 California condors have been treated for lead poisoning this hunting season in California.
User comments : 0
More news stories
Listen up: Oysters may use sound to select a home
Oysters begin their lives as tiny drifters, but when they mature they settle on reefs. New research from North Carolina State University shows that the sounds of the reef may attract the young oysters, helping ...
New experiments reveal the types of bacteria involved in human decomposition
The type of bacteria involved in human decomposition can change over time, according to new research published October 30th in the open-access journal PLOS ONE, by Aaron Lynne and colleagues at Sam Houston State University and Ba ...
Researchers use microscope equipped camera to learn how ticks pierce and adhere to skin (w/ Video)
(Phys.org) —A team of researchers from the U.S. and Germany has succeeded in filming ticks as they pierce the skin of a mouse ear, attach themselves and then start sucking blood. In their paper published ...
The secret math of plants: Biologists uncover rules that govern leaf design
Life scientists from UCLA's College of Letters and Science have discovered fundamental rules of leaf design that underlie plants' ability to produce leaves that vary enormously in size. In their mathematical ...
Methane-decomposing bacteria from hot springs need the valuable metals to produce energy
Rare earths are among the most precious raw materials of all. These metals are used in mobile telephones, display screens and computers. And they are apparently indispensable for some organisms as well. A ...
Virtual-reality goggles go beyond gaming
The $300 goggles that Irvine, Calif.-based Oculus VR began shipping to software developers in March deliver a glimpse of a futuristic technology that's been long awaited by video gamers. They allow a player ...
Baby brains are tuned to the specific actions of others
Imitation may be the sincerest form of flattery for adults, but for babies it's their foremost tool for learning. As renowned people-watchers, babies often observe others demonstrate how to do things and ...
Norwegian village uses giant mirrors to capture the sun
Sun-starved residents of a remote Norwegian village unveiled an ingenious mirror system Wednesday to bring natural light to their mountain valley home and liberate them from darkness that envelops them six ...
Archeologists find booty from pirate Blackbeard's ship
Five large cannons from a sunken ship captained by the legendary pirate Blackbeard have been recovered by US archeologists, authorities confirmed Wednesday.
Study shows ability to do next-generation sequencing for patients with advanced cancers
A pilot study led by the Translational Genomics Research Institute (TGen) and the Virginia G. Piper Cancer Center at Scottsdale Healthcare shows that, even for patients with advanced and rapidly transforming cancer, researchers ...
-
- Nanotechnology
- Physics
- All Physics
- General Physics
- Condensed Matter
- Optics & Photonics
- Superconductivity
- Plasma Physics
- Soft Matter
- Quantum Physics
- Space & Earth
- Electronics
- Technology
- All Technology
- Internet
- Software
- Business
- Engineering
- Semiconductors
- Other
- Telecom
- Energy & Green Tech
- Computer Sciences
- Hi Tech & Innovation
- Chemistry
- Biology
- Medicine & Health
- Other Sciences
© Phys.org™ 2003-2013
33 minutes ago by Julie Cart, Los Angeles Times
In the small, rural community of Reserve, children waiting for the school bus gather inside wooden and mesh cages provided as protection from wolves. Parents consider the "kid cages" a reasonable precaution.
Defenders of the wolves note there have been no documented wolf attacks in New Mexico or Arizona. Fears of wolves attacking humans, they say, are overblown, and the cages nothing more than a stunt.
In 1995, the reintroduction of Canadian gray wolves into the northern Rockies ignited a furor.
Now that acrimony has cascaded into the Southwest, where the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposes to extend Endangered Species Act protections for an estimated 75 Mexican wolves in the wild in New Mexico and Arizona.
Such protections would make it illegal to kill wolves, in most instances. The new federal plan would also significantly expand the area where the wolves could roam unmolested.
To many conservatives in the West, such protections are examples of government overreach - idealistic efforts by officials who don't know what it's like to live with wolves.
"People have to stand up and defend our rights," said Wink Crigler, a fifth-generation rancher from Arizona who says guests at her tourist cabins fear they might be attacked by wolves.
Anti-wolf campaigns here - paid for by conservative political organizations antagonistic toward the federal government - often portray the animal as a savage devil preying on children.
The antipathy has encouraged scores of illegal killings of Mexican wolves, whose population dwindled to seven before federal efforts to reintroduce them began in 1998. A young male was fatally shot with an arrow a few weeks ago in the same rural Catron County that uses the kid cages.
Into this atmosphere have come federal officials who by the end of the year are expected to finalize their plan for managing Mexican wolves, a smaller and tawnier subspecies of the Canadian grays.
"With the political debate we see raging, we can't just listen to the loudest voice in the room," said Fish and Wildlife Service Director Dan Ashe. "There are many loud voices in the room. No animal engenders more polarizing emotion among Americans than does the wolf."
He could be describing the situation here: a public policy debate driven not by biology and science but emotional appeals and unalloyed partisanship.
When a previously scheduled Oct. 4 public comment hearing about wolf management was postponed by the government shutdown, advocates came out anyway, staking out nearby meeting rooms at an Albuquerque hotel.
The Save the Lobo rally, paid for by Defenders of Wildlife, featured a man in a wolf costume, children scrawling placards with crayons and people offering videotaped testimony to be forwarded to Washington.
Down the hall, the anti-wolf event was sponsored by Americans for Prosperity, an organization funded by the conservative Koch brothers. The group offered literature by Ayn Rand and screened the documentary "Wolves in Government Clothing," which equated rampaging wolves with an out-of-control federal government. Said one Arizona rancher at the event: "Is this politically driven? Absolutely."
An armed guard patrolled, made necessary, Americans for Prosperity said, by death threats from environmental groups.
The issue of public safety loomed large, with much discussion of the kid cages, boxy structures that resemble chicken coops. Photos and video of the cages have been circulated by Americans for Prosperity, although it was unclear how many exist or who requested or paid for them. Local media reports suggest at least some of them were built by students in a high school shop class.
Calls to the superintendent of schools in Reserve were not returned.
To Carolyn Nelson, a teacher in Catron County, the cages don't go far enough to protect children. She said that seven years ago her son, then 14, was out walking and came across three wolves. Frightened, he backed against a tree. One wolf stared him down while the other two circled.
Only when the boy cocked the gun he was carrying did the wolves run off.
"I think it was a miracle he wasn't killed," she said.
Crigler, the Arizona rancher, who also attended the event, said she understands the fears of the guests in her tourist cabins. "I can't tell them that they are perfectly safe. There is some degree of risk," she said. "My concern is that I see wolves habituated to people. They are meat eaters. Savages."
According to wolf researcher Carlos Carroll, who was among the scientists studying Mexican wolves for the Fish and Wildlife Service, the probability of wolves targeting humans is low.
"All we can go on is what has happened in the past," said Carroll, a conservation biologist with the Klamath Center for Conservation Research in Northern California. "There have been maybe two to three attacks in the last decade, in Canada and Alaska, where there are thousands of wolves."
Wolf advocate Michael Robinson with the nonprofit Center for Biological Diversity said he respected people's fears but added, "The risk has been greatly exaggerated for cynical reasons."
Likewise, the incidence of wolves killing cattle and sheep is actually much less common than widely believed. According to the National Agricultural Statistics Service, about a third of sheep deaths nationwide are attributable to predators, with wolves accountable for only 0.4 percent of those attacks. The data indicate that domestic dogs are responsible for nearly 20 times more sheep kills than wolves.
Similar numbers hold true for cattle, where wolf kills rank behind coyotes, domestic dogs, cougars and vultures, which have attacked calves.
Ranchers are compensated when they can prove livestock have been killed by wolves. Crigler lost three calves last year and was reimbursed by a government program, but she said the payment was below fair market value.
"It's already hard enough to make a living," she said, adding that a neighboring cattleman was getting ready to walk away from the business because of wolves.
It's undeniable that small ranchers and farmers face economic troubles - and it's common for some people to feel powerless living in states where the federal government is the landlord of more than half the landscape.
But some anti-wolf advocates in Albuquerque hold wolves responsible for such diverging issues as the depopulation of small towns to the closing of country schools.
"They attach a lot of rancor to wolf recovery that isn't about wolves," said John Horning, executive director of WildEarth Guardians, based in Santa Fe, N.M. "It's a symbol. It's about the loss of political capital, the economic decline of rural life. Wolves are a surrogate for all the changes that are happening that are very frightening."
David Spady, the California director of Americans for Prosperity and producer of the anti-wolf documentary, readily agreed that wolves are a launching pad to air an array of grievances, from taxes to state's rights.
"The whole debate over the wolf is part of other battles over the Endangered Species Act and failed government programs," said Spady, who wore silver wolf-head cuff links.
"The wolf is symbolic of a larger fact: The federal government is running roughshod over private property rights," he said. "We at the local level believe that we understand the needs of our place rather than somebody in Washington, D.C."
Explore further: Plan lifts Lower 48 wolf protections (Update)
©2013 Los Angeles Times
Distributed by MCT Information Services
subspecies vs species
Oct 29, 2013I am trying to get a better understanding of subspecies vs species notably for humans. For example are Neanderthals a... Effect of microwave on food
Oct 26, 2013Hello All, Does microwave radiation cause change in protein chain structure? direction of magnetic field of earth and brain
Oct 23, 2013does direction of magnetic field influence the process occurring in brain? what are the other external factor that... Diffusion Constant
Oct 23, 2013Hey everybody, first post here. Having some trouble with a biophysics questions. So, the question is basically this:... How does exercise accelerate glucose uptake in diabetes?
Oct 23, 2013We're usually just told that exercise is a great way to stimulate the movement of glucose into cells. But how does it... Why the shaking in transformation?
Oct 23, 2013When performing transformation, after adding SOC media to the newly transformed cells, we place them at 37 degrees... More from Physics Forums - Biology
Related Stories
Plan lifts Lower 48 wolf protections (Update)
Jun 07, 2013
The Obama administration is proposing to end recovery efforts for gray wolves across most of the U.S. and return management to the states.
Draft rule ends protections for gray wolves
Apr 26, 2013
Federal wildlife officials have drafted plans to lift protections for gray wolves across the Lower 48 states, a move that would end a decades-long effort that has restored the animals but only in parts of ...
Wolves to come off endangered list within 60 days
Apr 16, 2011
(AP) -- Federal wildlife officials say they will take more than 1,300 gray wolves in the Northern Rockies off the endangered species list within 60 days.
Wolves howl because they care
Aug 22, 2013
When a member of the wolf pack leaves the group, the howling by those left behind isn't a reflection of stress but of the quality of their relationships. So say researchers based on a study of nine wolves ...
Wolf negotiations resume, but no consensus
Dec 03, 2010
(AP) -- Interior Secretary Ken Salazar and governors from three Northern Rockies states resumed negotiations Thursday to remove the region's wolves from the endangered list, but reached no conclusions.
Endangered wolves at NY preserve produce 8 pups
May 08, 2012
(AP) -- Eight rare Mexican wolf pups have been born at a preserve in the New York City suburbs, a development that could aid the federal program that has reintroduced the endangered species to the wild.
Recommended for you
15 Hawaii animals, plants added to endangered list
5 hours ago
The federal government says an eyeless shrimp and 14 other Hawaii creatures and plants have been added to the endangered species list.
Dry seeding examined for Wheatbelt crops
8 hours ago
Agronomy scientists have been conducting a series of experiments to help Wheatbelt farmers climate-proof their crops.
Biological activity and biotransformation of enniatins from Fusarium fungi
8 hours ago
Mould species of the genera Fusarium and Altenaria are considered the most important threats to Norwegian grain cereals because they produce toxins which can be a potential risk to food safety.
Porpoises on European coasts maintain their populations but migrate southwards
8 hours ago
Seven oceanographic research vessels and three light aircrafts from the SCANSII Project have recorded the abundance and distribution of small cetaceans in the waters of the European Atlantic shelf. Their results reveal that ...
Radical new 'Trojan Female' pest control approach shows great promise
9 hours ago
An innovative, non-lethal approach to pest management has the potential to become a "game-changer" in providing lasting and effective control in a wide range of insect and animal pests, according to New Zealand scientists ...
LA Zoo treats 21 condors for lead poisoning
Oct 29, 2013
Officials say a record 21 California condors have been treated for lead poisoning this hunting season in California.
User comments : 0
More news stories
Listen up: Oysters may use sound to select a home
Oysters begin their lives as tiny drifters, but when they mature they settle on reefs. New research from North Carolina State University shows that the sounds of the reef may attract the young oysters, helping ...
New experiments reveal the types of bacteria involved in human decomposition
The type of bacteria involved in human decomposition can change over time, according to new research published October 30th in the open-access journal PLOS ONE, by Aaron Lynne and colleagues at Sam Houston State University and Ba ...
Researchers use microscope equipped camera to learn how ticks pierce and adhere to skin (w/ Video)
(Phys.org) —A team of researchers from the U.S. and Germany has succeeded in filming ticks as they pierce the skin of a mouse ear, attach themselves and then start sucking blood. In their paper published ...
The secret math of plants: Biologists uncover rules that govern leaf design
Life scientists from UCLA's College of Letters and Science have discovered fundamental rules of leaf design that underlie plants' ability to produce leaves that vary enormously in size. In their mathematical ...
Methane-decomposing bacteria from hot springs need the valuable metals to produce energy
Rare earths are among the most precious raw materials of all. These metals are used in mobile telephones, display screens and computers. And they are apparently indispensable for some organisms as well. A ...
Virtual-reality goggles go beyond gaming
The $300 goggles that Irvine, Calif.-based Oculus VR began shipping to software developers in March deliver a glimpse of a futuristic technology that's been long awaited by video gamers. They allow a player ...
Baby brains are tuned to the specific actions of others
Imitation may be the sincerest form of flattery for adults, but for babies it's their foremost tool for learning. As renowned people-watchers, babies often observe others demonstrate how to do things and ...
Norwegian village uses giant mirrors to capture the sun
Sun-starved residents of a remote Norwegian village unveiled an ingenious mirror system Wednesday to bring natural light to their mountain valley home and liberate them from darkness that envelops them six ...
Archeologists find booty from pirate Blackbeard's ship
Five large cannons from a sunken ship captained by the legendary pirate Blackbeard have been recovered by US archeologists, authorities confirmed Wednesday.
Study shows ability to do next-generation sequencing for patients with advanced cancers
A pilot study led by the Translational Genomics Research Institute (TGen) and the Virginia G. Piper Cancer Center at Scottsdale Healthcare shows that, even for patients with advanced and rapidly transforming cancer, researchers ...
-
- Nanotechnology
- Physics
- All Physics
- General Physics
- Condensed Matter
- Optics & Photonics
- Superconductivity
- Plasma Physics
- Soft Matter
- Quantum Physics
- Space & Earth
- Electronics
- Technology
- All Technology
- Internet
- Software
- Business
- Engineering
- Semiconductors
- Other
- Telecom
- Energy & Green Tech
- Computer Sciences
- Hi Tech & Innovation
- Chemistry
- Biology
- Medicine & Health
- Other Sciences
© Phys.org™ 2003-2013
Source: southwest - Google News http://news.google.com/news/url?sa=t&fd=R&usg=AFQjCNFDTSMBz95yqpc0FFQTY7zAZYtbSw&url=http://phys.org/news/2013-10-wolf-hackles-southwest.html
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar